Name: Witch's Brew Iced Coffee
Prep time: 10 min
Total time: 10 min
Ingredients: 7 cups Dunkin’ Donuts Cold Brew Coffee; 5 cinnamon sticks; 1/2 cup hazelnut creamer; 1 tablespoon whole cloves; 6 stars of whole star anise; 1 teaspoon fresh nutmeg; 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract

This post may contain Affiliate Links. Please read our privacy policy here.

Jump to Recipe

This yummy, spiced coffee punch is perfect for Halloween parties, brunches and get togethers! Plus, it’s so smooth tasting and easy to make!

Side on shot of a black mug with iced coffee punch in it

We’re excited about getting so close to Halloween! We’ve been doing all the festive Halloween activities like watching our favorite Halloween movies, visiting the pumpkin patch, Halloween parties and more.

Every year it gets even more fun as the kids get older. There’s nothing better than reliving the holidays through your kids and making them memorable for your family!

How To Make Witch’s Brew Iced Coffee – A Coffee Punch Recipe – Step By Step

Table of Contents

In a large pitcher add in 4 cups cold water and 1 package (2 coffee packs) of cold brew coffee.
Add in the spices and let it steep overnight.
In the morning, remove the coffee packs and strain the cold brew through mesh to remove the spices.
Pour back into the pitcher and add in 3 cups of cold water.
To make the punch, add in ½ cup hazelnut creamer and ½ teaspoon vanilla extract and stir. Pour over ice and enjoy!

side shot of 4 cauldron mugs with garnish

To celebrate and continue our Sugar and Charm coffee series, we came up with the most delicious Witch’s Brew Iced Coffee, seasoned with yummy spices and made into an iced coffee punch!

Dunkin’ Donuts Cold Brew has become a new favorite in our home. It’s literally the easiest cold brew I’ve ever made and it’s so incredibly smooth. This time, we added in some spices as it steeped in the refrigerator overnight.

overhead shot of dunkin donuts cold brew pack

The way I describe the flavor of this coffee punch is almost like a coffee chai! It’s absolutely delicious!!

Make Ahead Of Time

If you’re hosting a morning Halloween party, get-together or brunch, this would be such a fun recipe to serve! Of course, it’s also good to make and keep in the refrigerator for yourself and family to enjoy throughout the week too!

shot of iced coffee punch being poured into a mug

side shot of a big cauldron with cream being poured in

An Coffee Punch That’s Steeped In Flavors

Once the coffee steeps overnight with the spices, I strained it though a mesh strainer to remove the whole spices. Then added hazelnut creamer, vanilla and ice to it.

Use Dry Ice For Extra Spookiness!

To create the smokey look, we added dry ice around the outside of the cauldron. Inside, I used a smaller plastic container for the coffee punch. This was solely for presentation, but you can serve this right out of a pitcher as well! Enjoy!

Top Tips For Iced Coffee Punch

If you have a preference for adding ice, and don’t want to dilute your cold brew too much, try ice cubes made out of coffee!
Make sure you allow the spices to steep overnight, for a rich flavor.
Keep the coffee punch refrigerated until you wish to serve, this way when you add ice cubes they will not melt straight away.
Make sure you strain out the spices before serving.

Check Out These Other Tasty Punch Recipes

Spiked Apple Cider Punch

Peach French 75 Punch Recipe

Algonquin Bar Punch

Candy Cane Peppermint Punch

close up shot of black cauldron mugs with cinnamon sticks

This post is sponsored by Walmart and Dunkin’ Donuts

If you have tried this iced coffee punch recipe or any other recipe on Sugar and Charm, then please rate it and let me know how it turned out in the comments below!

You can also FOLLOW ME on FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM and PINTEREST to see more delicious recipes and party ideas!