Whatever you want to call them easy cheesy scalloped potatoes, cheesy potato casserole, or potatoes au gratin, this potato dish is rich and creamy! This recipe is truly the best for super cheesy scalloped potatoes and a must on your holiday table!

We make this classic side dish every year for Thanksgiving and they’re always a hit. A cheesy potato casserole with cream, gruyere cheese, onions, shallots, and tender gold potatoes. Every bite is full of flavor and goes so well with turkey and the best Thanksgiving stuffing. These cheesy potatoes are rich, creamy, and absolutely divine!

Scalloped potatoes are an incredible dish that is sure to satisfy the whole family. They’re cheesy, creamy, rich potatoes that are the perfect side dish for our ham recipe or turkey.

You can cook them for any holiday meal from thanksgiving to Christmas or you can dish them up to your family for Sunday dinner. We also like to make these on Easter Sunday too and other special occasions too.

If you’re interested in learning how to make the perfect cheesy scalloped potatoes recipe, this helpful guide is for you. Let’s take a look at everything you need to know about scalloped potatoes to whip up the perfect dish.

How to Make Scalloped Potatoes 

What You’ll Need

• 10 x 15 Baking Dish  or 9×13 Casserole Dish
• Mandoline slicer – Optional but better for thinly slicing.
• Saute Pan
• Knife
• Measuring Cups
• Cheese Grater 

Ingredient Notes (Full Recipe In Recipe Card Below) 

These cheesy scalloped potatoes are made with simple ingredients that you can find at your local grocery store.

• Yellow Onion – This adds flavor and texture.

• Shallots – This is a small bulb that resembles an onion.

• Butter + Olive Oil – Both of these ingredients add so much flavor. Use organic unsalted butter when possible.

• Gold Potatoes – Gold potatoes have a creamy texture. They are ideal for baking and for scalloped potatoes because of their creamy texture. You can also try Yukon gold as well.

• Heavy Cream – The cream baked with the potatoes gives the dish the creamiest texture and flavor. You can also use whole milk if you prefer.

• Gruyere Cheese – A rich and creamy cheese with a nutty flavor. It melts nicely and has a wonderful taste! If for some reason you can’t find gruyere cheese you can try Swiss cheese.

• Nutmeg – Adds a nutty flavor to the dish.

• Salt + Black Pepper – Season and enhance all of the flavors in the dish.

How to Store

After whipping up your favorite Scalloped potato recipe with cream, you should make sure to store any leftovers in an airtight container. The dish can be kept inside the refrigerator and reheated alongside other Thanksgiving leftovers, such as savory stuffing or green bean casserole. 

How to Reheat

For the best results, when reheating your scalloped potatoes, you’ll want to remove them from the freezer and allow them to thaw first.

If you don’t, you can end up drying out the potatoes, rather than getting the rich, moist, cheesy goodness we all know and love. Plus, cooking the potatoes from frozen can increase the cooking time.

To make sure you get the best-scalloped potatoes possible, add a little cream to the dish after it’s defrosted. This helps loosen up the potatoes and add moisture back to the dish. 

How to Freeze

You might want to store your cheesy potato casserole for use later down the line. To do so, you can package them up in rigid freezer containers. From there, seal the containers tightly and place them in the freezer. 

If you want to freeze the potatoes in their original baking dish, cut a sheet of wax paper to the size of the dish and cover the potatoes. From there, cover the dish with aluminum foil. No matter how you choose to freeze your potatoes, you can store them for several weeks at a time in the freezer. 

How to Make Ahead

To help save time in the middle of the holiday hustle and bustle, you can make scalloped potatoes ahead of time. The easiest way to make scalloped potatoes ahead of time is to assemble the dish without cooking anything. 

Leave out any perishable ingredients, such as cream, until you’re ready to prepare the dish. This will help keep it from spoiling. 

After you’ve put together the dish, cover it and put it in the refrigerator. You can leave it in the fridge for several days before you cook it, saving you time when preparing Thanksgiving dinner on the big day.

Recipe Variations

If you’re wanting to take your cheesy scalloped potatoes to the next level, you can do so with a few easy variations. Here is a couple we recommend trying out: 

• Add bacon or ham
• Bake your potatoes in the slow cooker or skillet instead of the oven
• Swap potatoes for parsnips or golden beets
• Sprinkle with fresh chives
• Add spicy chile for a kick

These are just a few of the many ways you can mix up your scalloped potatoes!

Tips for Making Scalloped Potatoes

To help you make the best-scalloped potatoes possible, there are a few things you can do. Here are a few of our favorite tips for making the perfect scalloped potatoes: 

• Choose the right type of potato
• Use a mandoline to get your potato slices as thin as possible
• Don’t allow your potatoes to discolor
• Make sure the milk doesn’t curdle
• Cook the dish until the potatoes are just tender
• Let the dish rest before serving

With these simple tips, you’ll be ready to whip up the best cheesy scalloped potatoes you’ve ever tried!

Potatoes

The best potatoes for potatoes au gratin are starchy potatoes. A few of our favorite starchy potatoes include:

• Russet potatoes
• Yukon golds
• Idaho potatoes

Starchy potatoes release a creamy, white liquid when cooked. This blends perfectly with the other flavors in the dish, making for a tasty potato bake!

Frequently Asked Questions

More Recipes You’ll Love

If you’re looking for more recipes to add to your holiday dinner, here are a few of our favorites:

Homemade Sweet Potato Pie – Truly one of the best pies.

Sweet Potato Casserole with Marshmallow Fluff – Another classic dish we always have on our holiday table.

How to Make Cranberry Sauce – An easy, traditional recipe for cranberry sauce.

The Best Orange Cornbread – Flavors or orange cardamon make this one of our favorites.

Creamy Brussels Sprouts – Another delicious, creamy side dish.

Thanksgiving Appetizer Platter – One of our favorite appetizers to serve for a Friendsgiving.

Serve this dish with our favorite fall cocktail recipes or the best apple cider drinks.

Make the Perfect Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes Recipe with Cream 

With these tips and tricks, you’re ready to get started making the perfect cheesy potato casserole! It’s time to roll up your sleeves and get started whipping up your favorite scalloped potato recipe. 

Let us know what you of these homemade scalloped potatoes by leaving a comment and review below! 

You can also FOLLOW US on FACEBOOK, and PINTEREST to see more delicious recipes, cocktails, desserts, and parties!